Bookstore Glossary Library Links News Publications Timeline Virtual Israel Experience
Anti-Semitism Biography History Holocaust Israel Israel Education Myths & Facts Politics Religion Travel US & Israel Vital Stats Women
donate subscribe Contact About Home

Germany Virtual Jewish History Tour

By David Shyovitz and Mitchell Bard

Today, 118,000 Jews live in Germany, making it the eighth largest Jewish community in the world.

Learn More - Cities of Germany:
Bavaria | Berlin | Beckum | Cologne | DortmundDresden | Duesseldorf | Essen | Frankfurt | Munich | Nauheim | Pomerania | Offenbach

Early History (4-11th Century)
The Crusades & Middle Ages
German Jews in the Modern World
The Holocaust
Rebuilding a Modern Community

A Jewish Chaplain
Holocaust Remembrance
Relations With Israel
Germany and BDS
The Post-Merkel Era


Early History (4th - 11th Century)

Evidence of Jews in the area now known as Germany dates back to the early 4th century; in the 1930s, a Jewish graveyard from that era was found in the city of Cologne. When the first Jews migrated to the “barbarian lands,” Christianity had not yet arrived in Western Europe, and the Roman Empire was still the continent’s dominant power. Little is known about the early German Jews, but by the 8th century, Jews were flourishing among the German tribes along the banks of the Rhine. The Jews, for the most part, lived in harmony with their new Christian neighbors. Jews could hold public office, own land, and work in whatever industries they chose; they spoke the same languages and often had the same names as the Germans. Many Germans even converted to Judaism.

Ancient Jewish Cemetary in Worms

That is not to say that life in Germany was stable. Like all countries at this point, there was no unified German state. Early on, Germany consisted of several tribes, often vying with one another for territorial control. Later the tribes joined into a loose confederation, which resulted in a semi-autonomous “Kingdom of Germany.” Nonetheless, frequent civil wars and bids for power quickly destroyed any semblance of national unity. After Charlemagne united much of Western Europe in the eighth century, Germany was a part of the Holy Roman Empire, which itself fell victim to occasional civil wars and fragmentation after Charlemagne’s death. The turmoil of the frequent wars and political disputes among the Empire, Kingship, and various feudal estates was compounded by the emergence of the Roman Catholic Church as a force.

The Church had, by this point, codified much of its doctrine, including the attitude that the Jews were a rejected people who must be separated decisively from the Christians. Appeals from the Church to the Christian world to shun the Jews economically and socially date back to the Theodosian Code of the fifth century and were periodically reissued by Church synods. In Germany, however, the Church’s efforts to prejudice the Christian rulers and people against the Jews largely failed in this era – people were too concerned about the political fluctuations and simply surviving in the harsh frontier conditions to heed the call to discriminate.

An additional factor that endeared the Jews to the rest of society was their economic role. While the Jews also worked as farmers and artisans, like the rest of society, they came to acquire a special reputation as merchants. Rulers and populace alike, desperate for the goods that only the Jews could provide, were unable and unwilling to obey the dictums of the church; the very fact that so many decrees were issued is evidence of the apathy of Christendom in responding to them. The emerging Jewish merchant class created a vast international network that traversed the Ashkenazi world. Jews would meet at regional fairs to learn about the fates of other communities, networks, and trade. The economic and social connections that the Jews formed throughout the continent made them much more valuable than non-Jewish merchants, whose influence seldom reached beyond their immediate surroundings.

The “Golden Age” that resulted for European Jews was interrupted occasionally by anti-Semitism, but, for the most part, Jews lived happily. In the tenth century, European Jewry’s most important intellectual movement began to thrive when Rabbenu Gershom ben Judah (960-1028) founded a yeshiva in Mainz, Germany. Gershom’s school attracted Jews from all over Europe, including the famous Rashi; Gershom became so renowned for his genius and prominence that he posthumously acquired the moniker “light of the exile.” The study of the Talmud increased, and the German yeshivas in Mainz and Worms overshadowed those in Persia, the previous center of Jewish intellectualism.

The Crusades & Middle Ages

A 15th-century German painting
of a Jewish wedding

The Golden Age ended for the Jews of Western Europe on November 26, 1095. In Clermont, France, Pope Urban II made a public appeal to the Christians of Europe to liberate the city of Jerusalem from the Muslim Turks, who had closed it to pilgrims. This appeal marked the inception of the First Crusade. One result of the Crusade, whether intended or otherwise, was that the era of cooperation between Christians and Jews immediately ceased. With Christendom unified with a single purpose, the Jews were now viewed as outsiders and were rumored to be allied with the Muslims. Crusaders would routinely massacre whole Jewish communities on their way to the Holy Land. Communities in Worms, Mainz, and Cologne were devastated; in Mainz, for example, 1,100 Jews were killed in one day in 1096, and the synagogue and other communities’ buildings were razed. It is important to note that while the Pope occasionally condemned these attacks on Jews, the condemnations were neither vocal nor frequent. Moreover, the lack of any punishment or reprisals against the violators of the Pope’s orders gave the rioters implicit approval, and the attacks continued during the next seven crusades in the 12th and 13th centuries.

A German illuminated Passover Haggada, 14th century

While none of these future Crusades were as devastating to the German Jews as the first, which caught them unaware, their lives and communities were nonetheless changed irrevocably. Jews ceased to be exclusively a merchant class; much of Europe was now accessible after having been traversed by Crusaders, and non-Jews could perform international trade. Instead, in line with the Jews’ newfound subjugation at the hands of the Church, Jews became known as moneylenders. Because Christians could not lend money at interest, Jews had a niche waiting for them. Of course, such a profession did little to endear the Jews to their neighbors, some of whom would just as soon kill the moneylender as repay his loan.

Jews’ community lives changed as well. No longer could Jews hold public office or blithely interact with their Christian neighbors. Instead, the Jews of each city banded together in ghettos. While the word has acquired a decisively negative connotation in the aftermath of the Holocaust, the ghettos of Medieval Germany were locked from the inside as well as from the outside. No Jew could wander around the city without risking taunts and attacks, but few Jews had a reason or desire to leave the ghetto in the first place. The Jewish community, or kahal, was mostly autonomous – sometimes the ruler of the surrounding city would set limits on inhabitants of the ghetto, and they would always impose a heavy tax burden, but the collecting of taxes and enforcing of population quotas were all done by the Jewish governing board, the kehilla. The shtadlan, a community representative, handled any interaction with non-Jewish rulers, businessmen, or neighbors.

The collective isolation of the Jews also led to the rise of Yiddish. The Jews continued speaking a medieval German dialect, even as the language was advancing and changing in the outside world. The language gradually incorporated elements of Hebrew and eventually became a language unto itself, which was often incomprehensible to non-Jewish Germans.

The centuries following the Crusades were difficult for the Jews of Western Europe. In the thirteenth century, the Catholic Church instituted the Inquisition. Secular and religious rulers alike attacked “heretics” – a category that sometimes included Jews – with savagery, subjecting them to imprisonment, forced conversion, and often death. At the same time, the Jews were accused of killing children for ritual purposes (blood libels), host desecration, and, during the Black Plague in the fourteenth century, poisoning wells. These accusations and the violence that followed them (Juddenschlacht, or “Jews slaughter”), led to the repeated expulsion of the Jews of Germany from their towns. The evictions continued through the Middle Ages and the Reformation and resulted from the uncertain status of Jews as citizens of the cities they lived in. Within each German city, the ruler granted the Jews certain rights in a charter. This charter set the taxes the Jews would pay, outlined the area of the city they could live in, and guaranteed them protection; the remainder of the laws were left in the hands of the kehilla. In essence, the Jews agreed to become the property of whichever ruler granted them a protective charter. This agreement occurred on the largest scale in 1236, when Emperor Frederick II issued the Servi Camerae Nostrae (“Servants of the Treasury”), which formally made the Jews the property of the empire. Implicit in the charter agreements was that the charter could be rescinded whenever the region's ruler wished – and the regional rulers frequently did so.

A genizah collection stored at a museum in Worms, which stands on the spot of what was once Rashi’s house

Nonetheless, the Jews never fully abandoned Germany. Even when a city-state expelled the Jewish population, the disunified character of Germany ensured that another autonomous city would extend them a charter. Their reason for doing so was generally economic – the Jews could be counted on to fill the role of a moneylender, and, despite the gains made by Christians in international trade, Jews were still considered excellent merchants. The Jews would thus settle in a new location; eventually, the economic role they served would become unnecessary as Christians began to be crowded out of their industries. When this happened, violence against the Jews inevitably ensued, and expulsion followed. In this way, the Jews constantly wandered through Europe, residing in each city temporarily. In general, they moved east. As a result, by the late fifteenth century, the center of world Jewry had moved from Western Europe to Eastern Europe, with Jews mainly concentrated in Poland.

One positive result of the Jews’ new economic station was the rise of the court Jew. Because Jews controlled the loan of money, the feudal lords in Germany and elsewhere in Europe became dependent on the more prominent Jews for funds. The Jewish advisors were often single-handedly responsible for helping a Lord raise an army, build a palace, or furnish some public facility. These advisors were sometimes able to help a community escape a riot or an expulsion. For example, Joseph Oppenheimer (1699-1739), one of the most prominent court Jews in Germany, used his position to convince the Duke of Wurttemberg to rescind an expulsion order that had barred Jews from living in his duchy in the south of Germany.

In general, the Jews migrated within Germany in the Middle Ages from the towns on the Rhine in the south to the east and the north. By the thirteenth century, communities were forming in Munich, Vienna, and Berlin, which would become important Jewish cities in Germany in the modern era.

In the Reformation period, Jews continued to be physically and economically oppressed – those who were not expelled shouldered a crippling tax burden. Additionally, Martin Luther, after failing to convert the Jews to Protestantism, savagely denounced them, which led to more religiously inspired violence against them.

German Jews in the Modern World

The tombstone of Moses Mendelsohn is the only one still standing in Berlin’s Jewish cemetery.

The status of the Jews began to change in the seventeenth century when absolutist (and later enlightened absolutist) states became common. The rulers of these kingdoms viewed the interests of the state as supreme and began to realize that the Jews were a valuable commodity that was wasted when expelled. The rulers of Prussia, Hamburg, Bradenburg, and Pomerania, to name a few, welcomed Jews into their territories; however, the invitation came with numerous strings attached. The life of the Jews was highly regulated to ensure that the state extracted as much value as possible from them; laws were issued addressing employment, family life, residency, and communal affairs. The expulsions that the Jews had become accustomed to became increasingly rare as this era progressed.

The readmission of the Jews to many German states continued in the eighteenth century when the charters extended to them and granted them rights more and more similar to those of citizens. At the same time, however, the autonomy that had been a hallmark of Jewish communal life for centuries began to decline. As the Jews became more like citizens, the rulers withdrew their independent governance. For example, when Frederick II revised the charter of the Jews of Prussia in 1750, he included strict rules regarding the workings of the kahal.

The appearance soon afterward of the Haskalah, the Jewish reaction to the enlightenment, furthered the gradual dissolution of the Jewish semi-autonomy. Jewish thinkers and authors began to criticize the insularity of the Jewish community and emphasize secular and worldly pursuits in place of the traditional Jewish lifestyle and religion. As a result, many Jews left the ghetto to pursue education (if and when a school would admit Jews), brought their disputes to secular as opposed to religious courts, and befriended non-Jews. The most well-known example of this latter phenomenon was the friendship of Moses Mendelsohn (1729-1786) and G.E. Lessing in Berlin. However, it was an atypical example, for while Mendelson remained scrupulously observant, most maskilim did not, which seriously eroded Jewish unity in Germany.

The decline of the kahal continued in the aftermath of the French Revolution. When the revolution leaders declared, in 1789, that all the French would be granted “Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity,” they included the Jews. Thus, the Jews became full citizens of France, a status that was later withdrawn and then reinstated by Napoleon. This emancipation and the revolution against the British happening in the New World set a precedent that began to be followed throughout Europe. Various cities and states granted the Jews full equality or instituted reforms that were meant to culminate in emancipation at a later date. In 1812, Prussia became the first German state to grant citizenship to its Jewish inhabitants after years of lobbying by the maskil David Friedlander (1750-1834), Mendelsohn’s protege. Soon, the kahal ceased to exist as an essential institution; eventually, it ceased to exist.

The new status of the Jews, however, was not achieved without opposition. In 1819, the masses vented their frustration at the Jews’ rapid economic and political rise in the “Hep Hep” riots. Many peasants were less willing to let go of their conception of the Jews than the Jews were to let go of their conceptions of themselves.

The renovated New Synagogue in East Berlin

The new open, cosmopolitan atmosphere had its impact on religion as well. Frustrated with traditional observance, which they viewed as overly restrictive and irrelevant to modern life, many Jews joined the Reform movement. The first Reform Temple was founded in Hamburg in 1817, marking a dramatic departure from the traditional prayer service. Soon, Reform Temples opened elsewhere, too, and Berlin became the center of the movement. The “Neo-orthodox” school opposed reform, the brainchild of Samson Raphael Hirsch (1808-1888) of Frankfurt, which emphasized strict traditionalism combined with worldly pursuits. Meanwhile, Zecharias Frankel (1801-1875) laid the groundwork for the Conservative movement in Breslau.

The Jews of Germany were by now an overwhelmingly urban, professional class. Many participated in the German Revolution of 1848 and the resulting Frankfort parliament.

The Revolution of 1848 caused all the German states to proclaim emancipation. “The fundamental rights of the German people” (published on December 27, 1848), which were to serve as the norm for every constitution of the German states, declared that “civil and political rights are not conditioned by religion or restricted as a result of it” and that “religion must not diminish civic obligations.” This article was included, in one form or another, in the basic constitutions of most German states (Prussia, April 6, 1848, December 5, 1848; Wuerttemberg, December 21, 1848, January 14, 1849; Baden, November 17, 1849) and was even preserved in the “constitutions” of the early reactionary period. Article 12 of the Prussian Constitution (January 31, 1850) declared “freedom of religion and the freedom of organization of religious societies,” and, further, that “the use of civic and political rights is not dependent on religion,” nor does the “use of religious freedom impair civic and political obligations.” This article appeared to be a firm guarantee for the emancipation of Jews.

On November 1, 1867, all restrictions on the Jews’ right of residence, acquisition of real estate, and choice of profession were abolished in the states of the North German Confederation. These restrictions were similarly abolished in southern Germany (Bavaria in 1861; Wuerttemberg in 1862; Baden in 1864). The law of equality was passed by the Parliament of the North German Confederation on July 3, 1869. With the extension of this law to the states united within the German Empire (Bavaria, April 22, 1871), the struggle of Germany’s Jews for emancipation succeeded.

In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, anti-Semitism became more visible and even manifested itself in politics but was dismissed by the urbane, assimilated Jews as merely a passing social phenomenon. The anti-Semitism became more pronounced after World War I in Weimar Germany. For the most part, however, the prosperity and legal equality of the Jews continued unabated until Hitler’s rise to power in 1933 and the legal discrimination and violence that ensued.

Jewish social life in the inter-war period consisted of a struggle between Jewish nationalism and assimilationism. While many Jews tried as hard as they could to assimilate and distinguish themselves from their “Eastern” counterparts – i.e., the Jews in Eastern Europe who were still largely observant and traditional – others advocated a return to Jewish autonomy, either within Europe or in Palestine. The foremost proponent of Jewish autonomy was Theodor Herzl (1860-1904), the founder of political Zionism, who lived in Vienna. Regarding scholarship, German Jews enjoyed a “Jewish Renaissance” in the early twentieth century. Many books and treatises were published, the Hebrew language was resurrected as a living language, and Yiddish drama and newspapers flourished.

Some Jews immigrated in this period, mostly to America or Palestine; many more did so after the Nazis began to persecute them. The majority of Jews, however, remained in Germany, with catastrophic results.

The Holocaust

A synagogue burns in Memel on Kristallnacht.

The Nazi takeover of 1933, which resulted in Adolph Hitler (1889-1945), a virulent anti-Semite, becoming chancellor, was a stunning blow to German Jews. That year, the parliament passed the Enabling Act, essentially giving Hitler dictatorial powers. In 1935, the Nuremberg Laws were adopted; these laws officially defined Judaism in terms of race and withdrew the citizenship of all Jews. The situation escalated in 1938 when Germany annexed Austria. The atrocities perpetrated there against Jews soon became common in Germany proper as well. On November 9, 1938, Kristallnacht, Jewish businesses, and synagogues were razed, and Jews were hurt and killed in rioting.

The government persecution led to increased solidarity among German Jewry. Communities banded together to promote immigration and provide many services the government had stripped away. After the war began, these communal organizations were transformed into the Reichsvereinigung der Juden in Deutschland (Reich Union of Jews in Germany), headed by Leo Baeck.

In March 1941, Hitler officially ordered the implementation of the “Final Solution,” which resulted in Jews being forced to wear a yellow star as identification and being transferred en masse to ghettos and concentration and labor camps throughout Europe. The biggest of these camps was Auschwitz, located in Poland, where Jews were put to work as slave laborers and eventually killed in gas chambers. The Reichsvereinigung was sometimes forced to assist the Germans in implementing the final solution.

On May 19, 1943, Germany was declared Judenrein (“free of Jews”), though it is estimated that as many as 19,000 Jews remained in Germany underground.

Learn more about the Holocaust in Germany - CLICK HERE

Rebuilding a Modern Community

Following the Holocaust, Jews settled in Germany once again. The Jewish population consisted of three types: those who lived in Germany before the war and returned to their homes, displaced persons from elsewhere in Europe who took refuge in Germany, and those Germans who had never been discovered by the Nazis and had remained in Germany throughout World War II. About 1,500 Jews survived the Holocaust in hiding in Berlin. 

The total number barely reached five percent of the Jewish population before the war.

Memorial marking the spot where Berlin’s 55,000 Jews were gathered for deportation

This number decreased further as many German Jews immigrated to Israel in the 1950s. By the mid-1960s, communities were solidified in West Berlin, Munich, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf, Hamburg, and Cologne, consisting of about 20,000 Jews. Less than a thousand Jews lived in East Germany, and those who did were concentrated in East Berlin. Other Jews unaffiliated with the established communities also lived in Germany, but it is impossible to know precisely how many.

For a long time, the communities were primarily elderly men and women, and opportunities for Jewish life were minimal: few communities conducted daily prayer services, only two Jewish schools existed, and the two Jewish weekly newspapers had only modest circulations. Intermarriage became rampant. Because of reparations paid to Holocaust survivors and their descendants by the German government, the communities in Germany were among the richest in the world. The reunification of Germany, which repatriated Jews in East and West Germany, also increased Jewish opportunities and unity in the country. The Holocaust destroyed Jewish rural life in Germany, and after the war, very few Jewish individuals settled anywhere but in major German cities. 

Beginning in the late 1980s and continuing through 2004, the long-stagnant communities started to change. Vast numbers of immigrants came from the former Soviet Union. The influx of Soviet Jews revitalized community life, kosher food and restaurants, and grass-roots organizations. Germany’s open-door policy also created problems and tensions with Israel. Nearly 250,000 ex-Soviet Jews applied for entry to the country, and approximately 190,000 were allowed in. More than half vanished after acquiring financial aid from the government and social support from Jewish agencies. Israel became concerned in 2004 when twice as many ex-Soviet Jews immigrated to Germany as went to Israel. After Israel complained, the Germans began to tighten the criteria for Jewish immigration from the former Soviet Union, insisting on an age limit of 45 and requiring the ability to speak, read, and write German.

These stricter immigration rules made it more difficult for Jews from the former Soviet Union to enter the country in recent years. In May 2020, some of the regulations were relaxed, allowing Jewish immigrants 60 and older, as well as disabled adults of any age, to enter without demonstrating they can integrate into German society. The changes would also make family reunification for parents and Jewish spouses easier.

Today, the number of Jews in Germany is estimated to exceed 100,000, including non-affiliated Jews and descendants of mixed marriages. While the German Jewish communities have traditionally observant members, the population has become increasingly liberal; in 1995, the founding of the Association of Conservative and Reform Jews successfully challenged the einheitsgemeinde, the unified, traditional communities that had existed since the 1950s. Assimilation and intermarriage remain significant social problems.

The Jewish Museum Berlin in the Kreuzberg district, a division of the Berlin Museum, officially opened in 2001 and is notable for its location and collection. It is located on Lindenstrasse and contains a myriad of Judaic items and artifacts, some more than 800 years old, and a stirring Holocaust exhibit. The museum also features the Libeskind Building, designed and built by architect Daniel Libeskind. His design was modeled after a deconstructed Magen David (Star of David), and in the Fall of 2007, Libeskind’s Glass Courtyard, based on a sukkah opened, whose roof spans the 7,000-square-foot inner courtyard of the Old Building. The Jewish Museum in Berlin highlights the past and ongoing relationship between Germans and Jews in Germany. The architecture alone drew over 350,000 visitors to the building before the exhibits were unveiled.

The Chancellor of Germany signed an agreement with the Central Council of Jews in Germany on January 27, 2003, that officially raised the legal status of the Jewish community to the same level as the German Catholics and Protestants. This milestone took place on the anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz. Under this agreement, the German government must provide support, services, and funding to the Jewish community and nurture the existing German Jewish community. 

On November 9, 2006, the 68th anniversary of Kristallnacht (or “Night of Broken Glass”), Munich’s Jewish community celebrated the rededication of Munich’s main synagogue, which was destroyed on Hitler’s orders in 1938. The new synagogue and the accompanying Jewish community center opened to the public in 2007. Funding for the synagogue, which cost about $72 million, was provided by the city, the state of Bavaria, and Munich’s Jewish community.

The synagogue, called Ohel Jakob, is built of glass and steel, and the base is made of a white stone similar to the Jerusalem stone of the Kotel, symbolizing the Temple. The top of the synagogue represents the tent that housed the Tabernacle during the years of wandering in the desert. The building is located in St. Jakobs Square, only a few blocks from the original synagogue. The museum and community center also house an elementary school, library, and function halls. Between the community center and the synagogue, there is a memorial passageway. On one side, inscribed in layers of glass are 4,500 names of some of Munich’s Jews who were murdered in the Holocaust. A book accompanies the display with photos and biographical information.

Today, the Munich Jewish community has reached over 9,000 members, the same as before World War II. The city has four synagogues, including a separate liberal congregation with around 250 members. This growth is largely due to the influx of Jewish immigrants from the former Soviet Union in the 1990s.

On September 15, 2006, The Adam Geiger College ordained the first rabbis trained in Germany since the country’s last seminary closed in 1942. The three men were trained for four years at the Potsdam school, which is affiliated with the World Union of Progressive Judaism. While Chabad has ordained Orthodox rabbis in Berlin since the Holocaust, none had received their training in Germany. There are 120 Jewish congregations in Germany, but only twenty have full-time rabbis. Two of the newly ordained Reform rabbis plan to stay in Germany.

In March 2012, Peter Feldmann was elected as mayor of Frankfurt and became the first Jew to hold the position since the HolocaustFeldmann, who ran as a member of the Social Democratic Party, ran on a platform that advocated social reform but also confirmed that he is a strong advocate of Israel’s security and a supporter of Frankfurt-Tel Aviv relations. Frankfurt is Tel Aviv’s partner city, Feldmann said, adding, “Israel and Frankfurt have good contacts,” citing the “regular school exchange programs.” The mayor-elect is an economist who has vast experience in the social service field, has served as director of a senior citizen home, and even volunteered in his youth on a kibbutz in Israel. Frankfurt previously had one Jewish mayor, Ludwig Landmann, who was in office for nine years until the Nazis came to power in 1933.

The New Synagogue on Oranienburger Strasse in Central Berlin has operated since 1866. The synagogue was partially wrecked and badly damaged by fires on Kristallnacht and completely demolished by bombing planes in 1945. After the destruction of World War II, however, the German government restored the synagogue, and it now serves as a place of worship and a memorial and museum to German Jewish life in the pre-World War II period. The building is also used as the office building for the Berlin Jewish Community. 

Currently, Berlin houses the largest concentration of Jews in Germany, with about 50,000 Jews calling the city home in 2013. Today, more than 110 synagogues are dispersed throughout Germany.

German Foreign Minister Heiko Maas noted that in 2021, Germany is celebrating an anniversary. “Ancient documents have found that people of Jewish faith have been living in today’s Germany since the year 321.” He wrote, “This anniversary reminds us how deep our Jewish roots run, and of the great extent to which they shape who we are in Germany to this very day. What would our philosophy be without the thinking of Moses Mendelssohn or Hannah Arendt? What would the natural sciences be without Albert Einstein? How much poorer would our lives and our culture be without the music of Gustav Mahler, the poetry of Else Lasker-Schüler or the stories of Heinrich Heine or Franz Kafka?”

Also, in 2021, a new synagogue opened in Potsdam, the first built there since the end of World War II.

A Jewish Chaplain

In May 2021, it was announced that the rabbi of the German state of Saxony, Zsolt Balla, would become the Jewish chaplain to the German military. This is the first time a rabbi has been appointed since the Holocaust. Rabbis were first introduced as chaplains during World War I, the best-known being Leo Baeck. Hitler, however, dismissed all Jews from the military, including the Jewish chaplains,

The Budapest-born Balla was ordained in 2009, one of the first Orthodox rabbis trained in Germany since 1938. “That this is possible and becoming a reality after the inconceivable crimes committed by Germany makes me humble and grateful,” Defense Minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer said in 2019 after a state treaty was signed introducing chaplaincy for Jewish soldiers.

There are only an estimated 300 Jewish soldiers in the German military, the Bundeswehr. Balla said his role was to provide ethical foundations for the behavior of all soldiers. “It is another important task for us rabbis to also take preventive action against anti-Semitism among all soldiers.”

The remark was in the context of a series of scandals involving far-right networks in the police and the military. Germany’s Military Counterintelligence Service said in 2020 that some 600 Bundeswehr soldiers were suspected of right-wing extremism.

Holocaust Remembrance

Holocaust memorial on the site of what was the Jewish cemetery in Berlin.

In May 2005, the Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe, Germany’s official Holocaust memorial museum, opened in the center of Berlin. The memorial consists of a Field of Stelae covering an area of 19,000 square meters and containing 2,711 concrete blocks and an information center. The exhibition about the persecution and extermination of the European Jews and the historical crime sites was designed by Dagmar von Wilcken and attracts nearly half a million visitors each year.

The German government and the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany announced an increase in funding for social welfare services for Holocaust survivors by $88 million on July 10, 2018. This funding increase will allow survivors to receive more frequent and better quality home care, food support, transportation, and medical services. This allocation makes Germany’s 2019 total pledge to the Claims Conference $564 million.

At the end of 2018, Germany agreed to allocate $1.1 million for a new museum at the former Sobibor extermination camp in Poland.

German Stoplersteines

Throughout Germany, there are large bronze plaques artfully engraved with names and stories of individuals who perished at the hands of the Nazis. These are known as “Stolpersteine,” meaning “stumbling blocks.” These plaques are carved and engraved by hand by German artist Gunter Demnig, who began the project in 1997. Each begins with the words “Here lived...” and they are funded by the city where they will be placed. They are embedded in the sidewalks outside of the last known residences of individuals and minorities who were persecuted during the Holocaust. The first small memorial, embedded in the sidewalk, appeared in Berlin’s Kreuzberg district in 1996, and there are now more than 1,400 stumbling blocks throughout the capital. Not all communities have embraced these small memorials, and towns such as Villingen have refused to allow these privately funded memorials to be displayed on public property. The town council rejected proposals for the installation of the Stolpersteines in 2004 and again in 2013, and the 19 Stolpersteines that were created to commemorate the citizens of the village murdered during the Holocaust collect dust in the home of a local teacher.

Soccer club Borussia Dortmund, Daimler, railway operator Deutsche Bahn, Deutsche Bank, and Volkswagen agreed in 2019 to donate more than one million dollars for the construction of the “Shoah Heritage Collections Campus” at Yad Vashem to preserve, catalog, and store Holocaust-related artifacts.

In July 2019, the German government agreed to recognize some 8,000 Romanian citizens living in Israel as Holocaust survivors. Survivors and heirs from 20 cities and those who were incarcerated in ghettoes will be eligible for a monthly stipend and retroactive compensation from Germany in addition to payments of roughly $565 per month from Israel’s Holocaust Survivors Rights Authority.

In December 2019, Angela Merkel made her first visit to the Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial, donating about $65 million to help conserve the site. Germany was already the largest donor to the fund.

In a speech at Yad Vashem on January 23, 2020, German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier said, “I wish I could say that Germans have learned from history, but I can’t say that when hatred and agitation are spreading. I can’t say that when Jewish children are spat on in the school yard.”

In January 2020, the German government returned three works of art stolen during the Nazi occupation of France to descendants of their original owner, the collector and Jewish lawyer Armand Dorville who died in 1941. The three items were among the roughly 1,500 discovered in the home of Cornelius Gurlitt in 2013. Gurlitt’s father had been tasked with selling art taken from Jewish owners. Only 13 works have been returned to the families of the original owners.

In a ceremony on September 15, 2020, 75 years after the Gardelegen massacre, German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier said a resurgence of “authoritarian and nationalist thought” underlined the importance of a new memorial to the victims. “The massacre here at Gardelegen was one of the last,” Steinmeier said in the presence of two survivors. “It is essential that we remember. That we safeguard the memory of crimes which many Germans, even today, know nothing about.”

The German government amended its citizenship laws in 2021 to allow people and their descendants, stripped of their citizenship on political, racial, or religious grounds, to have it restored. In addition, people denied citizenship because they were born to a German mother but not a German father may apply for citizenship. Until 1953, German citizenship could only be passed on through the paternal line.

The new law also bars the naturalization of people convicted of racist, anti-Semitic, or xenophobic acts.

“This is not just about putting things right, it is about apologizing in profound shame,” said Interior Minister Horst Seehofer.

In June 2021, the United States and Germany agreed to launch a new dialogue on Holocaust issues and committed to working together on combatting Holocaust denial and distortion and finding innovative new ways to enhance Holocaust education.

In October 2021, Germany agreed to pay an additional $767 million in benefits to Holocaust survivors. After years of resisting, the government said it would compensate Russian Jews who survived the Nazi siege of Leningrad (St. Petersburg). An additional 2,000 Holocaust survivors who hid in France and Romania will also qualify for pensions, and 1,700 survivors who were children during the Holocaust and had previously received one-time payments will now be eligible for supplemental hardship payments in 2021 and 2022.

Also, in 2021, as the coronavirus pandemic continued, the German government committed $13.5 million to help ensure all Holocaust survivors can get vaccinated. Due to their ages, survivors are at higher risk of dying of COVID-19. 

In December 2021, the German government agreed to provide emergency funding of approximately $1,400 per person to about 150,000 Holocaust survivors. The funds, totaling about $200 million and referred to as the Supplemental Hardship Fund Payment, will go mostly to Russian speakers who had to flee the Nazis but were not imprisoned in concentration camps. The government agreed to accelerate the payments to help survivors deal with the financial difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

In March 2022, Germany agreed to provide another $720 million to provide home care and supportive services for frail and vulnerable Holocaust survivors. The New York-based Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany said the money will be distributed globally to more than 300 social welfare organizations. The additional funds constitute the largest amount ever allocated for the Claims Conference for welfare services in a single year, and the organization estimates the funds will pay for services for approximately 120,000 impoverished Holocaust survivors.

In September 2022, Germany agreed to extend long-term care benefits of 1,200 shekels ($350) monthly to about 14,000 survivors. The government will also provide 25 million euros for Holocaust education in 2023, 30 million in 2024, and 35 million in 2025. In addition, $12 million in emergency aid was earmarked for 8,500 Ukrainian Holocaust survivors and 170 million euros parceled out as 1,200-euro grants to 143,000 Holocaust survivors around the world, 81,000 of them in Israel.

The following year, Germany agreed to a record $1.4 billion package to pay survivors, increase funding for Holocaust education programs, and fund social welfare services administered through about 300 agencies across 83 countries. More than 128,000 survivors should receive hardship payments above their survivor pensions of about $1,360 in 2024, with small increases each year through 2027. About 120,000 survivors receive various types of support from Jewish social service agencies. Germany will spend $890 million on social services in 2024 as survivors age and need more care.


Throughout the post-war period, anti-Semitism continued, and neo-Nazi groups flourished throughout Germany. Hate crimes and membership in neo-Nazi groups have increased.  

In 2012, a study published by an independent committee of experts appointed by the Bundestag, the German parliament, found that anti-Semitism was on the rise in Germany, and not just from the neo-Nazi and Islamic fundamentalist parties. “Anti-Semitism in our society is based on widespread prejudices, cliches with deep roots and pure ignorance about everything to do with Jews and Judaism,” wrote one of the report’s authors, Dr. Peter Longerich. The study also criticized the way Germany deals with anti-Semitism. “There is no comprehensive strategy for fighting anti-Semitism in Germany,” said another of the authors, Dr. Juliane Wetzel. But despite the grim situation in Germany, the report noted that anti-Semitism is much worse in many other European countries, including Poland, Hungary, and Portugal.

A Jewish individual was attacked in Berlin on November 25, 2014, while leaving a synagogue. He sustained a black eye and multiple fractured fingers during the attack, which was perpetrated by a man who spoke German with an Arabic accent. According to the victim, there is no doubt that they were attacked because they looked like they were Jewish. 

Two Berlin-born Palestinian men were charged with planning attacks on the Israeli embassy and other Jewish institutions by a public prosecutor in Berlin in December 2015. Mohamed El-Nand  Ali El-I, both 21 years old, were charged with “planning a massive act of violence,” after their plans to bomb local synagogues and the Israeli embassy were reported to the police. The men were arrested in July 2015, and the trial began on December 15, 2015.

During the refugee crisis of 2015 spurred by civil war in Syria, the rise of the Islamic State, and general instability in the Middle East, Germany opened its doors to refugees from the war-torn region. As Germany took in thousands of these desperate refugees, the German Jewish community grew wary of a possible future rise in anti-Semitism in their country. The President of the Central Council of Jews in Germany, Josef Schuster, stated in a newspaper interview that intolerance and distaste for Israel and Jews is innate in much of the Middle East, and the rising immigrant population may lead to a rise in anti-Semitism in Germany as a whole. Schuster called for limiting the number of refugees allowed to enter the country in November 2015.

The German Ambassador to the United States, Peter Wittig, said in 2015, “These days we are facing a new type of anti-Semitism. Young Muslim Germans, often more or less recent immigrants, don’t identify with Germany’s history and special responsibility towards Israel in the way most Germans do.”

The number of Germans who espouse extreme political views rose by 9% from 2016 to 2017, according to a survey by Germany’s security agency Verfassungsschutz. The survey concluded that the number of Germans who associate with far-right extremist political parties had increased by almost 1,000 during that period and that there were at least 600 active Neo-Nazis in Germany. While this data is alarming, the Verfassungsschutz also found that violent crimes motivated by racism experienced a 35% decline from 2016 to 2017.

In 2017, a German government study revealed that nearly 33 million Germans held views reflecting the “contemporary anti-Semitism” of hating Israel. The report said 40% of Germans approved the statement: “Based on Israel’s policies, I can understand people having something against the Jews.”

The government revealed that in 2018, anti-Semitic offenses rose by about 10%. Physical attacks on Jews increased by 60%.

In an incident that went viral on the internet in early April 2018, 21-year-old Israeli Adam Armoush attempted to prove to a friend that Berliners do not harbor anti-Semitic feelings by filming himself walking the streets of Berlin while wearing a yarmulke. While filming, Armoush was assaulted on the streets by a Syrian refugee, who shouted anti-Semitic slurs and beat Armoush with a belt. In response, thousands of Germans of all faiths participated in a country-wide march against rising anti-Semitism on April 26, 2018. Marchers all wore kippot in solidarity with the German Jewish community.

A Syrian Jewish man was assaulted by a group of young adults in a Berlin park on July 7, 2018, after the youths recognized that he was wearing a Jewish Star necklace. The man had asked members of the group of young people for a light for his cigarette before the attack. When one of the youths realized that the victim was wearing a Jewish Star necklace, he began shouting anti-Semitic insults and punched the victim in the face.

In August 2018, a Jewish restaurant and its owner were attacked by masked neo-Nazis in the town of Chemnitz. The attackers allegedly threw stones, bottles, and a steel pipe at Uwe Dziuballa and shouted, Get out of Germany, you Jewish pig.

The Jewish community has been especially concerned by the rise of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party, which, since late 2017, is the biggest opposition group in parliament. In addition to its hostility toward Muslims, members of the party have made disparaging comments about the Holocaust. Party co-leader Alexander Gauland, for example, described the Nazis’ actions as a mere “speck of bird poo in over 1,000 years of successful German history.”

In April 2019, four Israeli children from economically disadvantaged families in Haifa traveled to Germany to see Borussia Dortmund play thanks to a financial gift from the Israeli branch of the German soccer team’s fan club. “When the bus drivers saw our Israeli passports, they immediately became aggressive and humiliated us,” tour guide Itamar Eli told the German publication Welt. Eli said the drivers then prevented the Israeli group from bringing their own food onto the bus while extending the same courtesy to other passengers.

German officials have taken a strong stand against anti-Semitism in recent years, reminding the country of its repressed past and its obligation to the Jewish people. German Chancellor Angela Merkel has been especially outspoken about her intolerance of anti-Semitism. On September 14, 2014, for example, she attended a rally against anti-Semitism in Berlin where she said, “I do not accept any kind of anti-Semitic message or attacks at all, not least the ones that were recently seen at the pro-Palestinian demonstrations.”

On May 25, 2019, Felix Klein, Germany’s anti-Semitism commissioner, provoked an international outcry when he told reporters he could “no longer recommend Jews wear a kippa at every time and place in Germany.” He said his opinion changed “following the ongoing brutalization in German society.”

Israeli President Reuven Rivlin angrily called the move “a surrender to anti-Semitism.” He said, “This capitulation shows that Jews are not safe, again, on German soil. We will never give in; we won’t lower our gaze and we won’t react with defeatism in the face of German anti-Semitism. We expect and demand that our allies respond in kind.” Rivlin added, “The responsibility for the peace, safety and freedom of the Jewish population of Germany is on the shoulders of the government and law enforcement agencies of Germany.”

Chancellor Angela Merkel’s spokesman reacted to the furor as well, “The state must see to it that the free exercise of religion is possible for all... and that anyone can go anywhere in our country in full security wearing a kippa,” Steffen Seibert told a press conference.

Klein subsequently called “on all citizens of Berlin and across Germany to wear the kippa next Saturday if there are new, intolerable attacks targeting Israel and Jews on the occasion of al-Quds day in Berlin.” He was referring to an annual protest over Israeli control of Jerusalem scheduled for the following Saturday.

Bild, Germany’s top-selling daily newspaper, published a cut-out-and-use kippa and called on readers to “stand in solidarity with (their) Jewish neighbors” by making their own kippa,” bearing the Star of David, to “raise the flag against anti-Semitism.”

On May 27, 2019, Chancellor Angela Merkel said, given its Nazi past, Germany has to be “much more vigilant than others” when it comes to nationalist movements across Europe. Merkel lamented that “there is to this day not a single synagogue, a single day care center for Jewish children, not a single school for Jewish children that does not need to be guarded by German policemen” and admitted, “over the years we have not been able to deal with this satisfactorily.”

On October 9, 2019, during a Yom Kippur service, a right-wing extremist live-streamed an attack on a synagogue in the town of Halle. Unable to get through a locked door where approximately 80 worshipers were barricaded, the man killed two people nearby and later injured two others. The death toll would almost certainly have been higher if he had managed to get inside the synagogue.

The gunman was initially able to escape when police arrived, but he was later apprehended. German Public Prosecutor General Peter Frank said the attacker “wanted to imitate others, but he also wanted to instigate others to imitate him.” Frank added, “He wanted to have a global impact.”

German Jews were angered when they learned there had been no police presence near the synagogue in Halle and demanded the government increase security at Jewish institutions.

Following the attack, Chancellor Angela Merkel’s Cabinet adopted measures to combat far-right extremism and anti-Semitism. The proposals include tightening gun laws, stepping up prosecution of online hate, and boosting financial support for projects fighting anti-Semitism and far-right extremism.

In December 2019, vandals overturned more than 40 gravestones and sprayed some with blue paint at a Jewish cemetery in Geilenkirchen. This was just one of 1,839 anti-Semitic incidents recorded in 2019, an increase from 1,799 in 2018.

In January 2020, Minister of Foreign Affairs Heiko Maas expressed fear that Jews might flee the country due to the rise in anti-Semitism and violence in this country.

A study released in February 2020 found that a fifth of German academics want the right to reject Israel’s existence on college and university campuses on free speech grounds.

In May 2020, the Kantor Center released its annual report on global anti-Semitism and reported: “Despite the major efforts in combating anti-Semitism, the alarming trend of growing anti-Jewish hatred and xenophobia continues, with a considerable increase in far-right activism and terrorism. In schools, anti-Semitic incidents among pupils are a common occurrence, including Israel-related anti-Semitism among Muslim communities ­– a phenomena that teachers are unprepared to handle.”

The German government reported in May 2020 that anti-Semitic crime had reached the highest level since 2001, with more than 2,000 incidents. Most were attributed to right-wing extremists.

Speaking at a ceremony in Berlin marking the 70th anniversary of the formation of the Central Council of Jews in Germany on September 14, 2020, Chancellor Merkel said, “We can be glad of flourishing Jewish life, but that is only one part of today’s reality. The other part of today’s reality is that many Jews don’t feel safe and respected in our country, and it causes me great concern.” She added that it is a “disgrace, and it shames me deeply, how racism and anti-Semitism are expressed in our country in these times.”

On October 4, 2020, a man wearing army fatigues and wielding a shovel attacked and seriously injured a Jewish student coming out of a synagogue in Hamburg where Sukkot was being celebrated. A 29-year-old man carrying a piece of paper with a swastika was arrested.

“This is not a one-off case, this is vile anti-Semitism and we all have to stand against it,” the German foreign minister, Heiko Maas, wrote on Twitter.

“To this day,” Maas lamented, “anti-Semitism has not disappeared. It just keeps shape-shifting. This is becoming evident in the wild conspiracy theories surrounding the Covid-19 pandemic. Anyone who marches through the streets of Berlin alongside right-wing extremists bearing a sign that reads “Impfen macht frei” (“vaccinations set you free,” referencing the quote “Arbeit macht frei,” or “work makes you free,” on the gates of Auschwitz), or storms the U.S. Capitol wearing a “Camp Auschwitz” sweatshirt, is not a peaceful protester but an anti-Semite.”

“All democrats have a duty to clearly call this out,” which is why he said Germany initiated a Global Task Force Against Holocaust Distortion. He noted it is a global fight because “the current digital nature of anti-Semitism means that it knows no borders.” Maas said, “Germany launched a European network focused on using education as a tool to combat antisemitic stereotypes.” He also called for greater political and financial support for “memorials, museums and educational institutions that deal with Holocaust-related issues.” Finally, he said social media needs to take greater responsibility regarding lies about the Holocaust.

In 2020, a project to combat anti-Semitism in Germany was introduced called “Meet a Jew.” The program sends pairs of Jewish volunteers to speak to non-Jewish groups—school classes, soccer teams, and interns at the foreign ministry. The idea is that while Germans are taught about the Holocaust, they don’t encounter Jews and understand their current problems.

In the wake of the global COVID-19 pandemic, some protestors against vaccines, lockdowns, and mask mandates have displayed yellow Stars of David like those Jews were required to wear by the Nazis. Several cities in Germany banned their use at demonstrations. In Dortmund, for example, the police chief said, “Anyone who displays the Jewish star in this way is trivializing the planned murder of millions of Jews by National Socialist Germany and endangering public peace.”

A survey by the  Allensbach Institute for Public Opinion Research found that 10% of the general German population saw physical assaults on Jewish individuals,14% saw attacks on Jewish property, 22% saw insults, mockery threats, or intimidation targeting Jews, and 41% observed jokes and discussion prejudicial to Jews or questioning the Holocaust. Most examples (61%) occurred on social media, 44% were in school or university, 40% in the streets, and 32% in a workplace or on public transportation. The main source, according to 43% of Germans, is right-wing ideas.

Sixty percent of Germans agree with the statement: “Jews are unfairly attacked when things go wrong.” A much smaller percentage (34%) agree with the statement “Jews today use their status as victims of Nazi genocide during World War II for their own benefit,” and only 18% agree with the statements “Jews have too much power in the media” and “Jews have too much power in politics.” Only 35% say blaming Jews for Israel’s policies is anti-Semitic, and an even smaller percentage (21%) consider calling Israel a racist state anti-Semitic.

The Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution reported that 3,027 anti-Semitic incidents occurred in 2021, an increase of nearly 29% over the previous year. Most were associated with right-wing extremism, but Islamic anti-Semitism also rose from 26 reported incidents to 122.

Relations With Israel

Today, Germany is one of the most reliable allies of the State of Israel. Limited diplomatic relations were established between the two states in 1956, and East Germany, as part of the Soviet bloc, was openly hostile. In 1965, relations between West Germany and Israel were fully normalized, even though the move led to the severance of relations between Germany and most Arab states. In the post-World War II era, Germany assisted the young state of Israel by providing infrastructure, including roads, railways, and public buildings. This also helped support German industries and helped the country bounce back after the war.

When the first post-war German Chancellor, Konrad Adenauer, met in New York City with Israel’s first Prime Minister, David Ben-Gurion, on March 14, 1960, it was an emotional and intense moment. After the meeting, it was announced that Germany had authorized $75-100 million in loans to Israel, but David Ben-Gurion was met with harsh criticism from Jews around the globe. When the Berlin Wall came down in 1989, Israelis held their breath, skeptical of the new unification and worried that a larger and more powerful Germany may not be as wary of its past. The unified German country has proven to be a valuable international ally and played a leading role in shaping the pro-Israel attitudes of many European countries.

Germany has pursued a close relationship with Israel in the post-World War II era to regain legitimacy on the international stage and attempt to reconcile with Jews around the globe. This support for Israel crosses party lines in Germany.

Germany has become one of Israel’s largest trading partners in Europe (in 2013, Israel imported $4.6 billion in German goods) and the source of its submarine fleet, other naval vessels, and military hardware. In 2015, for example, Israel purchased four Corvette ships and four Patriot missile batteries.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel became the first chancellor to address the Knesset in 2008, causing five members of the Knesset to storm out of the room. It is believed that they were protesting the fact that Merkel was speaking German in the Knesset building.

Political opinion polls show a divide between the government policy and the new generation of Germans coming of age. The German government officials base their political policy on the ties and events of the past, remembering the Holocaust vividly and basing their decisions on the strategic relationship shared with Israel and forged through this horror. The younger generation, however, wishes to take action and make judgments about Israel based on the current situation and Israel’s policies. One effort to ensure younger generations see the Germany-Israel relationship as crucial to the well-being of both nations is to increase Holocaust education in German schools. In 2013, Yad Vashem signed an agreement with education ministers from every German state that developed new and improved Holocaust education programs. 

Germany provided Israel with its fourth submarine in September 2014. The submarine was the first of the new generation of Dolphin submarines, with the capability of staying underwater significantly longer than the other three Dolphin-class submarines. A fifth German-built submarine arrived in Israel on January 12, 2016.

When German Chancellor Angela Merkel was asked during a joint press conference with Israeli PM Netanyahu about her opinion on the rush to do business with Iran following the implementation of the JCPOA, she told reporters that “there cannot exist normal, friendly relations with Iran as long as Iran doesn’t recognize Israel’s right to exist.” Merkel added, “there is a difference between being friendly, and talking to each other.”

On April 3, 2016, Der Spiegel disclosed that the German Federal Intelligence Service (BND) had been spying on Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu’s office. The report also confirmed that the BND spied on the Interior Ministries of Austria and Belgium, the UK Defense Ministry, the U.S. State Department, NASA, and others.

In November 2016, Germany’s Daimler Automotive group announced plans to develop an R&D facility in Tel Aviv. The facility will join Daimler’s other R&D centers in the United States, Germany, India, and China. The German automaker hopes that the Israel R&D facility will also stimulate “the development of a network of connections with Israeli startup companies, technology accelerators, incubators, innovation centers, and established high tech firms.”

A $32 million collaborative project was announced in November 2016 by the Israeli Innovation Authority and the German Ministry of Science, which aims to advance the field of nanotechnology. The funding will allow nanotechnology institutes and incubators in both countries to collaborate on joint projects for at least three years.

The German Parliament approved the purchase of 1,000 Israeli-made and designed Spike LR anti-tank guided missiles (ATGMs) and 97 corresponding launcher units in March 2017. The contract between the Bundeswehr (German military) and Rafael Advanced Defense Systems is worth $172 million and is expected to be completed over 20 years.  

German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier paid his first Presidential visit to Israel during the first week of May 2017. He had previously visited Israel when he served as Germany’s Foreign Minister. During his 2017 trip, he visited Yad Vashem, met with Israeli President Reuven Rivlin, and spoke with critics and proponents of Israel’s settlement policies. Speaking at Yad Vashem, Steinmeier remarked that we Germans have burdened ourselves with unfathomable guilt and praised the close relationship that Israel and Germany have shared over the years. 

Germany sent planes to participate in the annual Blue Flag exercise for the first time in June 2017. The German pilots joined 70 planes from Israel, the United States, India, France, Italy, and Poland in the largest aerial training exercise to ever take place in Israel.

The Social Democratic Party in the German Parliament blocked the lease of Heron TP drones from Israel in June 2017, citing the primary reason for their objection: the drones were capable of carrying weapons. Members of Parliament were quoted in German newspapers saying the deal was dead. The German Defense Minister announced that the German military had agreed to lease 3-5 Heron TP drones from Israel in 2016. The German military already uses the Heron TP’s predecessor, the Heron 1, in Afghanistan. Leasing the drones was expected to cost the Germans $650 million, assuming they would have been deployed in 2018. In early 2017, Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) was awarded a $652 million contract to supply additional Heron drones.

Israeli and German officials announced in late October 2017 the signing of a Memorandum of Understanding for the Israeli purchase of three additional Dolphin-class submarines from Germany.  

The German government signed $1 billion worth of arms deals with Israel in June 2018, including a $600 million agreement to lease multiple Israeli Heron TP military drones.  

Police carried out raids across Germany in April 2019, targeting charities suspected of providing “financial and propaganda” support to Hamas. Around 90 properties in ten states were searched, with the focus of the raids targeting the charities WWR Help and Ansaar International in North Rhine-Westphalia.

“Whoever supports Hamas under the mantle of providing humanitarian aid disregards the fundamental values of our constitution,” Interior Minister Horst Seehofer said. “This also discredits the commitment of the many aid organizations that have committed themselves to neutrality under difficult circumstances.”

In 2019, the Tagesspiegel newspaper reported that Hezbollah was recruiting members and raising funds for terrorism and weapons purchases. Hezbollah members “use Germany as a place for drug trafficking, trade in stolen cars and money laundering.” According to German intelligence, 1,050 Hezbollah members and supporters operate across Germany, and some 30 mosques and cultural centers have links to the organization.

In December 2019, the Bundestag passed a non-binding resolution calling on the German government to ban the activities of Hezbollah, which reportedly has more than 1,000 operatives in Germany. The government banned Hezbollah’s “military wing” in 2013 after the group was implicated in the July 2012 bombing of a bus carrying Israeli tourists in Bulgaria, where five Israelis were killed. Hezbollah’s “political wing,” however, continues to raise funds in the country. A foreign ministry official said the government preferred to “focus on dialogue,” which was interpreted as a way to avoid angering Iran.

Israeli and German fighter jets fly over the Knesset on October 17, 2021.
(Credit: Israel Defense Forces)

After years of Israeli and American lobbying, Germany’s interior ministry outlawed all Hezbollah activities within the Federal Republic in April 2020.. “The activities of Hezbollah violate criminal law and the organization opposes the concept of international understanding,” said the interior ministry. The same day, German police raided four Hezbollah-controlled mosque associations in Berlin, Dortmund, Bremen, and Münster. The decision to ban Hezbollah came after the Mossad reportedly provided German intelligence with information on Hezbollah’s activities, including the locations of warehouses storing ammonium nitrate, a common agricultural fertilizer that can be used in explosives.

German pilots have twice traveled to Israel for joint maneuvers, but on August 17, 2020, 75 years after the Holocaust, Israeli fighter jets landed in Germany for military exercises for the first time.

In June 2021, the German government banned the Hamas flag following a series of anti-Semitic incidents during anti-Israel rallies protesting Israel’s Guardian of the Walls operation. “We do not want the flags of terrorist organizations to be waved on German soil,” said Thorsten Frei, the deputy parliamentary spokesperson for Chancellor Angela Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union and its Bavarian sister party, the Christian Social Union.

In October 2021, the air forces of Israel and Germany participated in a joint military exercise. As a demonstration of friendship, jets flew together over Jerusalem. This was the first time German aircraft had flown over Jerusalem since World War I. “The flyby expresses the strong partnership and connection between the air forces and the countries, as well as the commitment to continued cooperation in the future,” the IDF said.

Israel and Germany’s ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems signed an agreement in January 2022 to purchase three Dakar-class diesel-electric submarines. The German government will provide nearly $680 million of the roughly $3.4 billion cost.

The two countries also signed an industrial strategic cooperation agreement worth more than $960 million, under which the German government will invest in Israeli industries such as defense companies. The Israeli Defense Ministry said the agreement, signed with Germany’s Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology, “will result in the opening of new markets, professional training, technological development, employment opportunities and a positive influx for both the Israeli economy and the defense establishment.”

In early February 2022, new Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock said she “deliberately made Israel my first port of call” to build on “the unique, close and diverse relations that we have with Israel.” Baerbock added, “It is nothing short of a miracle that in our two countries young people particularly are now so close to one another. We want to promote increased exchange among young people in order to safeguard this treasure for future generations – as a firm foundation on which to build our relations in the future and as an obligation never to allow our responsibility for the terrors of the Holocaust to be forgotten.”

New Chancellor Olaf Scholz made his first trip to Israel in March 2022 and met with Prime Minister Naftali Bennett.

An Allensbach Institute for Public Opinion Research survey asked Germans if they agreed or disagreed with former Chancellor Angela Merkel’s 2008 statement that Israel’s security is part of Germany’s national interest. Nearly half (48%) agreed, and 31% disagreed. 

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas was in Berlin on August 16, 2022, for a meeting with Scholz. He was asked to condemn the 1972 Olympics massacre committed by Palestinian terrorists. He refused, instead accusing Israel of “50 Holocausts.” He made the remark standing beside Scholz, who was criticized by Germans and Israelis for not immediately rebuking Abbas. The next day Scholz said, “I am disgusted by the outrageous remarks made by Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. For us Germans in particular, any relativization of the singularity of the Holocaust is intolerable and unacceptable. I condemn any attempt to deny the crimes of the Holocaust.” His spokesperson added, “His gaffe yesterday casts a dark shadow over Germany’s relations with the Palestinian Authority.”

Abbas’s office subsequently issued a statement, “President Mahmoud Abbas reaffirms that the Holocaust is the most heinous crime in modern human history.”

Israel hosted the first-ever Germany-Israel Strategic Dialogue involving senior national security officials in Jerusalem on September 1-2, 2022. This was a follow-up to an agreement reached in March to establish a framework for strategic cooperation. 

Israeli Prime Minister Yair Lapid made a 24-hour visit to Germany in September 2022 to lobby Chancellor Olaf Scholz to reject Iranian demands for concessions before agreeing to comply with the nuclear agreement (JCPOA).  “It is important that Iran does not develop a nuclear bomb,” Scholz told reporters in a joint press conference with Lapid.

The Russia-Ukraine war prompted Germany to increase its defense spending, and it looked to Israel for advanced technology. In 2023, Elbit Systems was awarded a contract to provide Airborne Electronic Warfare (EW) self-protection systems for Airbus Helicopters. Israel also received approval from the United States for its largest arms sale ever, a $3.5 billion contract for Israel Aerospace Industries to provide Germany with the Arrow 3 missile defense system.

“In the eyes of every Jew, there is a special significance to the fact that Germany is relying on the State of Israel for its defense, said Defense Minister,” Yoav Gallant.

In September 2023, Netanyahu met Scholz on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly and discussed strengthening security cooperation and Iran’s nuclear program.

Germany and BDS

European Union nations voted in November 2015 to label all products produced on Israeli land seized following the 1967 War as “made in settlements,” a move that prompted harsh criticism from Israeli officials. “The EU decision is hypocritical and constitutes a double standard,” said Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. “It singles out Israel and not the 200 other conflicts around the world. The EU has decided to label only Israel, and we are not prepared to accept the fact that Europe is labeling the side that is being attacked by terrorism. The Israeli economy is strong and will withstand this; those who will be hurt will be those Palestinians who work in Israeli factories. The EU should be ashamed.”

The President of the German Parliament announced that Germany did not support the decision to label the goods and rejected the idea when it was presented. During a joint press conference with Knesset speaker Yuli Edelstein, German Bundestag President Norbert Lammert said, “Germany can imagine a better law, if it were to apply to everyone, on principle, to all occupied land. Because it’s specifically against Israel, I repeat that it is unnecessary and not very smart.”

Germany has also been a leader in opposing the anti-Semitic boycott, sanctions, and divestment (BDS) campaign. In February 2017, for example, politicians from the Christian Democratic Union Party called BDS anti-Semitic. In August, Munich adopted anti-BDS legislation, and Frankfurt banned BDS activity. A month later, Berlin’s mayor vowed to block the use of city venues and funds by groups or event organizers that support BDS. In October, the Green Party in the southern German state of Bavaria passed a resolution rejecting BDS because it is “anti-Semitic, hostile to Israel, reactionary and anti-enlightenment.”

Students in Germany also have a clear understanding of BDS, which led Leipzig University to adopt an anti-BDS bill. For Germans, the boycott of Israel is distressingly familiar. As the student parliament at Goethe University in Frankfurt observed in this succinct and searing indictment of the movement:

The call by the BDS campaign to boycott products from the parts designated “occupied territories” of the West Bank, east Jerusalem and Golan Heights stands clearly in the tradition of the national socialist Jewish boycott and the slogan “Don’t buy from Jews!”

On May 17, 2019, the German Parliament became the first in the European Union to designate the BDS movement anti-Semitic. Members of the Bundestag said the campaign to boycott Israeli products, along with the movement’s “Don’t Buy” stickers, recalled “the most terrible chapter in German history” and revived memories of the Nazi motto “Don’t buy from Jews.” The resolution said, “The pattern of argument and methods of the BDS movement are anti-Semitic” and called for an end to funding any organizations that question Israel’s right to exist, call for a boycott of Israel or actively support BDS.

The Munich City Council said BDS is anti-Semitic and passed a resolution in December 2017 outlawing BDS events in the city’s public facilities. In 2022, however, a German federal court ruled the city’s refusal to allow a public venue to be used for a debate on the anti-BDS resolution was unconstitutional.

The Post-Merkel Era

Following the close election to succeed Merkel, the Social Democratic Party of Germany, the Free Democratic Party, and the Greens presented a coalition agreement on November 24, 2021, making Olaf Scholz of the Social Democrats the new chancellor. The deal included commitments to ensure Israel’s security, fight anti-Semitism, and promote Jewish life.

A statement by the Central Council of Jews in Germany said, “We are confident about the plans of the future federal government. A successful fight against right-wing extremism and anti-semitism are of crucial importance for the future of Germany.”

Charlotte Knobloch, a previous president of the organization and current leader of the Jewish Community of Munich, was more circumspect. “I think it sounds good, it has some positive declarations, but I will form my opinion on the new government not based on these words, but on action.”

In December 2022, the government approved the National Strategy against Anti-Semitism and for Jewish Life, which will focus on data collection, research, and accurate assessment of anti-Semitism; education as prevention; new approaches to Holocaust remembrance; increasing security; and making current and past Jewish life in Germany visible. The announcement came just days before authorities arrested 25 people from the far right plotting to overthrow the government.

On October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorists massacred hundreds of Israelis and prompted Israel to launch an attack to destroy the organization. Protests erupted around the world, including in Germany, supporting Hamas. In Berlin, two Molotov cocktails were thrown at the Kahal Adass Jisroel synagogue. Chancellor Scholz said, “We will never accept when attacks are carried out against Jewish institutions.”

On November 2, 2023, the government implemented a ban on Hamas and dissolved Samidoun, a group that was behind a celebration in Berlin of the Hamas massacre. Police subsequently searched the properties of Hamas members and followers. “We are continuing our consistent action against radical Islamists," German Interior Minister Nancy Faeser said. “By banning Hamas and Samidoun in Germany, we have sent a clear signal that we will not tolerate any glorification or support of Hamas' barbaric terror against Israel.”

Police also raided the homes of people in Bavaria who were accused of spreading anti-Semitic hate speech and threatening Jews online and those of a Hamburg-based organization suspected of supporting activities of Hezbollah.

The German Development Ministry announced on November 7, 2023, that it will continue to freeze its entire aid budget for UNRWA’s operations in Gaza. Germany has been UNRWA’s largest donor over the last five years, contributing almost $1 billion.


General Council of Jews in Germany
Zentralrat der Juden in Deutschland
President: Dieter Graumann
Postfach 04 02 07
10061 Berlin
Phone: +49 30 28 44 56 - 0
Fax: +49 30 28 44 56 - 13
Email: [email protected]

Jüdische Gemeinde Aachen
Synagogenplatz 23
52062 Aachen
Phone: +49 241 25770
Email: [email protected]

Israelitische Kultusgemeinde Amberg
Salzgasse 5
92224 Amberg
Phone: +49 9621 131 40

Israelitische Kultusgemeinde Schwaben-Augsburg
Haldererstraße 6-8
86008 Augsburg
Phone: +49 8215099313
Email: [email protected]

Israelitische Kultusgemeinde Baden-Baden
Werderstraße 2
76530 Baden-Baden
Phone: +49 7221 391 021

Sources: “Germany,” Encyclopedia Judaica,
Nicholas De Lange, The Illustrated History of the Jewish People. Harcourt Brace and Co.: New York, 1997,
Paul Mendes-Flohr and Judah Reinharz, The Jew in the Modern World: A Documentary History. Oxford University Press: New York, 1995,
Chaim Potok, Wanderings: History of the Jews. Alfred A. Knopf: New York, 1978,
Geoffery Wigoder, Jewish Art and Civilization. Walker and Co.: New York, 1972,
Jay Bushinksy, “Germany’s New Jews,” (JTA, February 2, 2005),
“New Synagogue to Open in Munich,” The Jerusalem Post, (November 9, 2006),
“Dateline: Dresden,” The Jerusalem Report, (October 16, 2006),
Melanie Lidman, “Munich’s Jews are there to stay,” Washington Jewish Week (January 24, 2008),
European Jewish Congress, “The Jewish Community of Germany,” EJC website, 2010,
World Jewish Congress, “Germany,” WJC website, 2011,
Ofer Aderet, “Anti-Semitism is Still Flourishing in Germany, Study Shows,” Haaretz, (January 24, 2012),
Benjamin Weinthal, “Frankfurt Elects First Jewish Mayor Since Holocaust,” Jerusalem Post, (March 29, 2012),
Amy Schwartz, “Inside the Germany-Israel Relationship,” Moment Magazine, (June 10, 2014),
“Netanyahu welcomes new submarine: This sends a clear message to our enemies,” Jerusalem Post, (September 24, 2014),
Merkel: Palestinian recognition not right path,” AP, (November 21 2014),
“Israeli man attacked in Berlin while leaving synagogue,” Times of Israel, (November 25 2014),
“50 Years of Israel-German Diplomatic Relations,” Embassy of the Federal Republic of Germany in Washington, (2015),
Lars Hoffman, “German Armed Forces Will Lease Israeli Drones,” Defense News (January 13, 2016),
Raphael Ahren, “Merkel: Germany won’t normalize ties with Iran unless it recognizes Israel,” Times of Israel (February 16, 2016),
Barbara Opall-Rome, “Israel To Double Heron UAV Recon Squadron,” DefenseNews (March 10, 2016),
Herb Keinon, “Report: German Federal Intelligence Service spied on Prime Minister’s Office,” Jerusalem Post (April 3, 2016),
Yuval Azulai, “Israel Aerospace to lease 5 drones to German army,” Globes, (June 29, 2016),
Dubi Ben-Gedalyahu, “Daimler to open Israeli R&D center,” Globes, (November 7, 2016),
Gedalya Reback, “Israel and Germany launch joint €30 million nanotechnology funding initiative,” GeekTime (November 13, 2016),
Before Netanyahu talks, Steinmeier vows to back Israel,, (May 8, 2017),
Udi Etsion. IAI wins bid to supply UAVs to German Air Force, YNet News, (June 1, 2017),
Gili Cohen. In First, Germany to Send Fighter Jets to Train in Israel, Haaretz, (June 21, 2017),
Gili Cohen. German Lawmakers Block Israeli Drone Deal After Discovering They’re Armed, Haaretz, (June 29, 2017),
Herb Keinon. Despite Ongoing Investigation, Israel and Germany Sign Submarine MOU, Jerusalem Post, (October 25, 2017),
James Masters. Germans of all faiths in ‘wear a kippa march’ against anti-Semitism, CNN, (April 26, 2018),
Germany signs billion-dollar drone lease deal with Israel, JNS, (June 14, 2018),
Jewish man assaulted in Berlin for wearing a Star of David, JTA (July 9, 2018),
Germany Increases Funding for Holocaust Survivors by $88 Million, Haaretz, (July 10, 2018),
Germany Experiences a Resurgence in neo-Nazis, Intel Agency Finds, Haaretz, (July 25, 2018),
Toby Axelrod, “Jewish restaurant owner injured, restaurant vandalized during German neo-Nazi riots,” JTA, (September 9, 2018),
“Germany allocates $1.1 million for new museum at former concentration camp site,” JTA, (December 27, 2018),
“Anti-Semitism: Germany sees ‘10% jump in offences’ in 2018,” BBC, (February 13, 2019),
Frank Zeller, “Germany anti-Semitic offenses rise sharply in 2018, mostly from far-right,” Times of Israel, (February 13, 2019),
“Police raids across Germany target alleged Hamas-linked charities,” Deutsche Welle, (April 10, 2019),
Ben Cohen, “Dream Trip to German Soccer Stadium for Israeli Kids Ends in Antisemitic ‘Humiliation’ on Bus Going Home,” Algemeiner, (April 8, 2019),
“5 German firms each give $1.1 million to Holocaust memorial,” AP, (April 2, 2019),
Jonathan Lis, “Rivlin Rebukes Germany’s ‘Surrender to anti-Semitism’ in Skullcap Warning,” Haaretz, (May 26, 2019),
“Germany changes course on warning against wearing kippa,” (AFP, May 28, 2019),
“Merkel Warns of Populists’ Rise in Europe,” AP, (May 28, 2019),
Luisa Beck and Rick Noack, “Synagogue attacker hoped to inspire further anti-Semitic attacks, German authorities say,” Washington Post, (October 10, 2019),
“Jews demand action from Germany after deadly anti-Semitic attack,” Times of Israel, (October 10, 2019),
Kirsten Grieshaber, “Germany ups fight against anti-Semitism, far-right extremism,” AP, (October 30, 2019),
Alex Winston, “Germany To Compensate 8,000 Romanian Holocaust Survivors,” Jerusalem Post, (July 21, 2019),
Benjamin Weinthal, “Hezbollah uses Germany to finance terrorism, weapons purchases,” Jerusalem Post, (December 2, 2019),
“In First Visit to Auschwitz, Merkel Presents 60-million-euro Donation,” Reuters, (December 6, 2019),
Soeren Kern, “German Parliament: Its Resolution to Ban Hezbollah is Just a Legal Charade,” Gatestone Institute, (December 23, 2019),
“Jewish cemetery vandalized in Germany, suspects investigated,” DW, (December 30, 2019),
“Germany returns artwork stolen by Nazis to French Jewish family,” AFP, (January 22, 2020),
Noa Landau, “Full Text of German President’s Yad Vashem Speech: We Germans Have Not Learned From History,” Haaretz, (January 23, 2020),
Benjamin Weinthal, “20% of German university academics reject Israel’s existence,” Jerusalem Post, (February 13, 2020),
Benjamin Weinthal, “Germany outlaws Iranian-backed terrorist organization Hezbollah,” Fox News, (April 30, 2020),
“Mossad gave Germany intel on Hezbollah before ban,” World Israel News, (May 2, 2020),
“Antisemitism Worldwide,” Kantor Center for the Study of European Jewry and the European Jewish Congress, (April 20, 2020),
Joe Baur, “Germany relaxes immigration rules for Jews coming from former Soviet Union,” JTA, (May 15, 2020),
Benjamin Weinthal, “More than 2,000 antisemitic crimes in Germany, highest rate since 2001,” Jerusalem Post, (May 27, 2020),
“75 years on: Germany marks site of one of last Nazi massacres,” AFP, (September 15, 2020),
Ben Cohen, “Merkel Laments Continuing’ Disgrace’ of Antisemitism in Germany in Speech to Jewish Leaders,” theAlgemeiner, (September 15, 2020),
Katrin Bennhold, “Attack at German Synagogue During Sukkot Raises Anti-Semitism Fears,” New York Times, (October 4, 2020),
Heiko Maas, “German foreign minister: anti-Semitism keeps shape-shifting. This is what we are doing to stop it,” CNN, (January 23, 2021).
David Rising, “Germany funds vaccine assistance for Holocaust survivors,” AP, (March 24, 2021).
Cnaan Liphshiz, “Germany enacts law favoring naturalization for descendants of ex-citizens who fled Nazis,” JTA, (March 25, 2021).
Wesley Dockery, “German government agrees to ban Hamas flag after antisemitic incidents,” DW, (June 20, 2021).
Christoph Strack, “Germany’s military appoints first rabbi since before Holocaust,” DW, (June 21, 2021).
“Germany passes new citizenship law for descendants of Nazi victims,” BBC, (June 25, 2021).
Toby Axelrod, “Potsdam’s stylish new synagogue is the German city’s first since WWII,” JTA, (August 27, 2021).
Neil Vigdor, “Germany Sets Aside an Additional $767 Million for Holocaust Survivors, Officials Say” New York Times, (October 6, 2021),
Judah Ari Gross, “German military planes fly over Jerusalem for 1st time since WWI in show of ties,” Times of Israel, (October 17, 2021).
Ian Lovett, “‘Meet a Jew’ Program Aims to Tackle Rising Anti-Semitism in Germany,” Wall Street Journal, (November 19, 2021).
Cnaan Liphshiz, “In coalition agreement, German parties vow to defend Jewish life and Israel’s security,” JTA, (November 25, 2021).
Cnaan Liphshiz, “150,000 Holocaust survivors to receive $200M in emergency COVID-19 funding,” JTA, (December 26, 2021).
Anna Ahronheim, “Israel, Germany sign agreement for three new submarines,” Jerusalem Post, (January 20, 2022).
“Germany: federal court rules anti-BDS policy to be ‘unconstitutional,’” Middle East Monitor, (January 26, 2022).
Toby Axelrod, “Dortmund is latest German city to ban yellow stars at COVID protests,” JTA, (February 9, 2022).
“Statement by Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock prior to her departure for the Middle East,” Press Release, Federal Foreign Office, (February 9, 2022).
“Germany to give $720 million to Holocaust survivors globally,” AP, (March 2, 2022).
“American Jewish Committee Surveys German General, Muslim Populations on Antisemitism,” American Jewish Committee, (May 10, 2022).
Toby Axelrod, “German government reports startling 29% increase in antisemitic crimes,” JTA, (June 9, 2022).
Ilan Ben Zion And Kirsten Grieshaber, “German leader condemns Abbas’ ‘50 Holocausts’ remark,” ABC News, (August 17, 2022).
Ruth Marks Eglash, “After trip to Berlin, Israel hopes West will adopt new approach on Iran” JewishInsider, (September 13, 2022).
Bar Peleg, “Israel, Germany Reach Deal on Boosting Holocaust Survivors’ Benefits,” Haaretz, (September 15, 2022).
Toby Axelrod, “As fear of local extremism grows, Germany approves first-ever government plan to combat antisemitism,” JTA, (December 7, 2022).
Dean Shmuel Elmas, “Israeli defense exports reach new peak,” Globes, (June 14, 2023).
Asaf Elia-Shalev, “Germany agrees to record $1.4 billion in annual Holocaust reparations as survivors age,” JTA, (June 14, 2023).
Yoav Zitun, “Largest arms deal in Israel's history: US approves sale of Arrow 3 to Germany,” Ynet, (August 17, 2023).
Amir Tibon, “Netanyahu, Erdogan Hold First Ever Face-to-face Meeting, Talk Saudi-Israel Normalization,” Haaretz, (September 20, 2022).
Toby Axelrod, “Police investigate 2 Molotov cocktail bombs thrown at German synagogue,” JTA, (October 18, 2023).
Kirsten Grieshaber, “Hundreds of German police raid properties of Hamas supporters in Berlin and across the country,” AP, (November 23, 2023).
“Germany announces freeze of all UNRWA aid in Gaza,” IMPACT-se, (November 27, 2023),

Photo Credits: Worms Cemetery photo courtesy of Aaron Hertzman.
Wedding and Hagadda illustrations courtesy of Alan Humm.
Fragments photo courtesy of Juedisches Museum Worms.
Mendelsohn’s grave and Berlin monument photos courtesy of Philip Greenspun,
New Synagogue photo courtesy of David Navarro.