Joshua, son of Jehozadak (515-490 BCE)
Ezra, son of Seraiah (Unknown)
Joiakim, son of Joshua (490-470 BCE)
Eliashib, son of Joiakim (470-433 BCE)
Joiada, son of Eliashib (433-410 BCE)
Johanan, son of Joiada (410-371 BCE)
Jaddua, son of Johanan (371-320 BCE)
Onias I, son of Jaddua (320-280 BCE)
Simon I, son of Onias (280-260 BCE)
Eleazar, son of Onias (260-245 BCE)
Manasseh, son of Jaddua (245-240 BCE)
Onias II, son of Simon (240-218 BCE)
Simon II, son of Onias (218-185 BCE)
Onias III, son of Simon (185-175 BCE)
Jason, son of Simon (175-172 BCE)
Menelaus (172-162 BCE)
Alcimus (162-159 BCE)
Jonathan Apphus (153-143 BCE)
Simeon Tassi, brother of Jonathan Apphus (142-134 BCE)
John Hyrcanus I, son of Simeon Tassi (134-104 BCE)
Aristobulus I, son of John Hyrcanus (104-103 BCE)
Alexander Jannaeus, son of John Hyrcanus (103-76 BCE)
John Hyrcanus II, son of Alexander Jannaeus (76-66 BCE)
Aristobulus II, son of Alexander Jannaeus (66-63 BCE)
John Hyrcanus II (63-40 BCE)
Antigonus, son of Aristobulos II (40-37 BCE)
Aristobulus III (37 BCE)
Ananelus (37-30 BCE)
Joshua ben Fabus (30-23 BCE)
Simon ben Boethus (23-5 BCE)
Matthias ben Theophilus (5-4 BCE)
Joazar ben Boethus (4 BCE)
Eleazar ben Boethus (4-3 BCE)
Joshua ben Sie (3 BCE - ?)
Joazar ben Boethus (? - 6 CE)
Ananus ben Seth (6-15 CE)
Ishmael ben Fabus (15-16)
Eleazar ben Ananus (16-17)
Simon ben Camithus (17-18)
Joseph Caiaphas (18-36)
Jonathan ben Ananus (36-37)
Theophilus ben Ananus (37-41)
Simon Cantatheras ben Boethus (41-43)
Matthias ben Ananus (43)
Elioneus ben Simon Cantatheras (43-44)
Jonathan ben Ananus (44)
Josephus ben Camydus (44-46)
Ananias ben Nebedeus (46-58)
Jonathan (58)
Ishmael ben Fabus (58-62)
Joseph Cabi ben Simon (62-63)
Ananus ben Ananus (63)
Joshua ben Damneus (63)
Joshua ben Gamaliel (63-64)
Mattathias ben Theophilus (65-66)
Phannias ben Samuel (67-70)

Sources: Wikipedia

The Jewish Temples: High Priests of the Second Temple Period