It is extremely difficult to locate sources about the Roma people in the Holocaust like those widely available about Jewish victims, which may reflect the difference between a literate culture and a largely illiterate one. It is known that perhaps 250,000 Roma were killed and that, proportionately, they suffered greater losses than any other group of victims except Jews.
Roma are an ethnic group originating from India which for unknown reasons took to a wandering lifestyle in the late middle ages. Eventually, the Roma they reached Europe and became part of the ethnic mix of many countries, contributing to areas such a music and the arts. Ironically, the German writer Johann Christoph Wagenseil claimed in 1697 that Roma stemmed from German Jews.
Although they were “Aryan” according to the Nazi racial typology, they were pursued relentlessly for persecution.
Roma in Auschwitz: Part 1
For Nazi Germany, the Roma became a racist dilemma. The Roma were Aryans, but in the Nazi mind there were contradictions between what they regarded as the superiority of the Aryan race and their image of the Roma people. One Nazi theorist believed that “the Gypsy (Roma) (Roma) cannot, by reason of his inner and outer makeup (Konstruktion), be a useful member of the human community.”1
The reports of the SS Einsatzgruppen which operated in the occupied territories of the Soviet Union mention the murder of thousands of Roma along with the massive extermination of the Jews in these areas.
The deported Roma were sent to Auschwitz-Birkenau, where a special Roma camp was erected. Over 20,000 Roma from Germany and some other parts of Europe were sent to this camp, and most of them were gassed there.
Roma from the General Government [Poland] who were not sent to Auschwitz and to the Operation Reinhard camps were shot on spot by the local police or gendarmes. In the eastern region of the Krakow district, in the counties of Sanok, Jaslo, and Rzeszow, close to 1,000 Roma were shot.
According to The Institut Fuer Zeitgeschicthe in Munich, at least 4,000 Roma people were murdered by gas at Auschwitz-Birkenau.
Roma in Auschwitz: Part 2
Like the Jews, Roma were singled out by the Nazis for racial persecution and annihilation. They were “nonpersons,” of “foreign blood,” “labor-shy,” and as such were termed asocials. To a degree, they shared the fate of the Jews in their ghettos, in the extermination camps, before firing squads, as medical guinea pigs, and being injected with lethal substances.
The Nuremberg Laws of 1935 aimed at the Jews were soon amended to include the Roma. In 1937, they were classified as asocials, second-class citizens, subject to concentration camp imprisonment.2 As early as 1936, some had been sent to camps. After 1939, Roma from Germany and from the German-occupied territories were shipped by the thousands first to Jewish ghettos in Poland at Warsaw, Lublin, Kielce, Rabka, Zary, Siedlce and others.3
It is not known how many were killed by the Einsatzgruppen charged with speedy extermination by shooting. For the sake of efficiency Roma were also shot naked, facing their pre-dug graves. According to the Nazi experts, shooting Jews was easier, they stood still,
while the Gypsies cry out, howl, and move constantly, even when they are already standing on the shooting ground. Some of them even jumped into the ditch before the volley and pretended to be dead.4
The first to go were the German Roma; 30,000 were deported East in three waves in 1939, 1941 and 1943. Those married to Germans were exempted but were sterilized, as were their children after the age of twelve. 5
How were the Roma of Europe
Open season was declared on the Roma, too. For a while Himmler wished to exempt two tribes and
only sterilize them but, by 1942, he signed the decree for all “Gypsies” to be shipped to Auschwitz.7 There they were subjected to all that Auschwitz meant, including the medical experiments, before they were exterminated.
Roma perished in Dachau, Mauthausen, Ravensbruck and other camps. At Sachsenhausen they were subjected to special experiments that were to prove scientifically that their blood was different from that of the Germans. The doctors in charge of this
research were the same ones who had practiced previously on black prisoners of war. Yet, for
racial reasons they were found unsuitable for sea water experiments.8 Roma were often accused of atrocities committed by others; they were blamed, for instance, for the looting of gold teeth from a hundred dead Jews abandoned on a Romanian road.9
Roma women were forced to become guinea pigs in the hands of Nazi physicians. They were sterilized as
unworthy of human reproduction (fortpflanzungsunwuerdig) and ultimately annihilated as not worthy of living.
For a while there existed a “Roma Family Camp” at Auschwitz, but it was liquidated on August 6, 1944. Some men and women were shipped to German factories as slave labor while the rest – about 3,000 women, children and old people – were gassed.10
No precise statistics exist about the extermination of European Roma. Some estimates place the number between 500,000 and 600,000, most of them gassed in Auschwitz.11 Others indicated a more conservative 200,000 Roma victims of the Holocaust.12
Roma in Auschwitz: Part 3
Roma were officially defined as non-Aryan by the Nuremberg laws of 1935, which also first defined Jews; both groups were forbidden to marry Germans. Roma were later labeled as asocials by the 1937 Laws against Crime, regardless of whether they had been charged with any unlawful acts. Two hundred Gypsy (Roma) (Roma) men were then selected by quota and incarcerated in Buchenwald concentration camp. By May 1938, SS Reichsfuehrer Himmler established the Central Office for Fighting the Gypsy (Roma) (Roma) Menace, which defined the question as
a matter of race, discriminating “pure Gypsies” from “part Gypsies” as Jews were discriminated, and ordering their registration.
In 1939, resettlement of the Roma was put under Eichmann’s jurisdiction along with that of the Jews. Roma were forbidden to move freely and were concentrated in encampments with Germany in 1939, later (1941) transformed into fenced ghettos, from which they would be seized for transport by the criminal police (aided by dogs) and dispatched to Auschwitz in February 1943.
During May 1940, about 3,100 were sent to Jewish ghettos in the Government-General: others may have been added to Jewish transports from Berlin, Vienna, and Prague to Nisko, Poland (the sight of an aborted reservation to which Jews were deported). These measures were taken against Roma who had no claim to exemption because of having an Aryan spouse or having been regularly employed for five years.
Some evaded the net at first. Despite a 1937 law excluding Roma from army service, many served in the armed forces until demobilized by special orders between 1940 and 1942. Roma children were also dismissed from schools beginning in March 1941. Thus, those who were nominally free and not yet concentrated were stripped systematically of the status of citizens and segregated. The legal status of Roma and Jews, determined irrevocably by the agreement between Justice Minister Thierack and SS Reichsfuehrer Himmler on September 18, 1942, removing both groups from the jurisdiction of any German court, confirmed their fate. Thierack wrote,
I envisage transferring all criminal proceedings concerning [these people] to Himmler. I do this because I realize that the courts can only feebly contribute to the extermination of these people.
The Citizenship Law of 1943 omitted any mention of “Gypsies” since they were not expected to exist much longer. Himmler decreed the transport of Gypsies to Auschwitz on December 16, 1942, but he did not authorize their extermination until 1944. Most died there and in other camps of starvation, disease, torture and abuse as live experimental subjects. By the end of the war, 15,000 of the 20,000 Roma who had been in Germany in 1939 had died.
First section: Yitzhak Arad, Belzec, Sobibor, Treblinka—The Operation Reinhard Death Camps. (IN: Indiana University Press, 1987), pp. 150-153.
Second section: Vera Laska, ed., Women in the Resistance and in the Holocaust: The Voices of Eyewitnesses, (CT: Greenwood Press, 1983).
Third section: Helen Fein, Accounting for Genocide: Victims and Survivors of the Holocaust. (NY: Free Press, 1979).
1Raul Hilberg, The Destruction of the European Jews, (Chicago: Quadrangle Books, 1961), p.641; quotation by Staatsrat Turner, chief of the civil administration in Serbia, October 26, 1941, in ibid., p. 438.
2Donald Kenrick and Grattan Puxon, The Destiny of Europe’s Gypsies, (New York: Basic Books, 1972), p.72.
3Jan Yoors, Crossing, A Journal of Survival and Resistance in World War II, (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1971), pp. 33-34.
4Hilberg, p. 439.
5Ruzena Bubenickova, et al., “Tabory utrpeni a smrti” (Camps of Martyrdom and Death), (Prague: Svoboda, 1969), pp. 189-190.
6Simon Wiesenthal, The Murderers Among Us,” (New York: Bantam, 1967), pp. 237-238.
7Kendrick, pp. 88-90.
8Hilberg, pp. 602, 608; the doctors were Hornbeck and Werner Fischer.
9Ibid., p. 489.
10Ota Kraus and Erich Kulka, “Tovarna na smrt” (Death Factory) (Prague: Nase vojsko, 1957), p. 200.
11Yoors, p. 34; Bubenickova, p. 190.
12Martin Gilbert, The Holocaust, Maps and Photographs, (New York: Mayflower Books, 1978), p. 22; Kendrick, p. 184.