Letter from House Speaker Criticizing Clinton Pressure on Israel
(May 6, 1998)
Letter sent May 6, 1998, from Newt Gingrich, Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, to President Clinton.
Dear Mr. President,
I have followed the recent changes in your administration's Israel policy
with a deep and growing sense of concern.
I strongly believe that genuine and lasting peace in Israel can only be
achieved through voluntary direct dialogue between the parties, and not as
a result of heavy-handed outside pressure by the United States. Israel
must be able to decide her own security needs and set her own conditions
for negotiations without facing coercion from the U.S.
If your administration uses its influence to unilaterally design a
“solution ” or force Israel to the table despite Israel's legitimate
concerns regarding terrorism, then we are removing any incentive for
Chairman Arafat and the Palestinian Authority to negotiate. What
motivation does Chairman Arafat have to move toward common ground when
America volunteers to drag Israel to his current position?
Worse, America's strong-arm tactics would send a clear signal to the
supporters of terrorism that their murderous actions are an effective tool
in forcing concessions from Israel. Such signals endanger Israel and
further weaken the peace process.
Our most loyal democratic allies in the region should not be punished with
threats and ultimatums, but given our fullest confidence as they attempt to
balance their mutual needs of peace and security. America's best
assistance can be offered as a facilitator, not a bully.
Your administration must re-evaluate it policy in this area.
Sincerely,
Newt Gingrich
Speaker of the House
|