Israel Proposes Rehabilitation of Refugees
(July 28, 1966)
This telegram updates the Embassy in Israel of a meeting between the U.S. Secretary of State and Israeli Ambassador Harmon and Envoy Gideon Rafael in which the Israelis proposed a solution to the refugee problem in which the focus would be on getting Arabs out of camps (in support of a speech made by Jordanian King Hussein) and rehabilitating them into the Arab world instead of merely focusing on repatriating them but keeping them in camps. Israel agreed that they would provide some financial support in the form of international financial assistance.
Telegram From the Department of State to the Embassy in Israel/1/
Washington, July 28, 1966, 3:49 p.m.
16922. 1. Israeli Envoy Gideon Rafael, accompanied by Amb. Harman, today presented to Secretary results of GOI task force deliberations on possible initiatives on refugee problem. He began by saying GOI has not made any decision, but would like to put forth some tentative proposals for our consideration.
2. Rafael said GOI eliminated possibility of any overall peace proposal because Arabs would not accept that. Repatriation means for Arabs driving Israel out of Mideast. This left rehabilitation-resettlement as only possible basis for progress.
3. He recalled US and UN had negotiated resettlement projects with Syria, Egypt and Jordan under UNRWA rehabilitation fund in early fifties, and then proposed we prepare ground at GA for creation of similar rehabilitation instrument financed by international subscription to which Israel could contribute with help of loans.
4. When Secretary asked if GOI excludes repatriation, Rafael said yes, at this stage, because repatriation is symbol of Arab hostility to existence of Israel. Time is ripe, he said, for rehabilitation and against repatriation which is not realistic basis for settlement. GOI is inspired by Hussein's speech,/2/ he said, and believes his ideas about "breaking down walls of UNRWA and getting refugees out of camps" should be encouraged.
5. In reply to question, Rafael said Jordan should be approached separately, because divisions in Arab world would prevent Arabs from acting as group. Lebanon would go along when feasible, Harman added.
6. When Secretary asked if GOI already in touch with any Jordanians on this, Rafael said no, GOI wanted first to discuss with USG. GOI does not want to make approach, he said.
7. He then added GOI for time being only wants to prepare groundwork at UNGA for this project, i.e. to conduct debate in such way as to show Arabs UNRWA is not permanent fixture, that UN will not respond to further Arab attempts to politicize this question. When Secretary asked if GA then would be final rather than first step, Rafael said first steps would be reform of UNRWA, reduction of relief rolls, elimination of PLA, then assuring that host states prepared to take over responsibility--these would prepare ground for this proposal.
8. Rafael asked if US would take up proposal with Jordanians. Secretary said USG could not take lead. If we broached idea, question of repatriation would immediately arise. He suggested Israelis might wish approach SYG Thant and ask him if he would take this up. Jordanians should be asked if King Hussein's speech indicated any Arab interest in rehabilitation, he added.
9. Rafael said this idea was GOI constructive approach to problem. If this not acceptable, he indicated, many felt GOI should simply take no action but remain strong and wait for more favorable time for dealing with refugee problem.
10. Secretary noted that Arabs know rehabilitation has been available to them from outset. He said he had no indication they had changed in their negative attitude toward it. He also cautioned that UN unlikely to forget repatriation aspect of resolutions.
11. Secretary concluded by stating he not rejecting suggestion "if you and Arabs agree on it," but indicated again Israelis should sound out Arabs through their own means.
12. Above is full record of conversation and no additional memcon being prepared.
13. Rafael's earlier separate conversations with Assistant Secretaries Hare and Sisco followed same line as above. Memcons by pouch./3/
/1/Source: National Archives and Records Administration, RG 59, Central Files 1964-66, REF PAL. Confidential; Noforn Except Israeli officials. Drafted by Campbell, cleared by Symmes and Sisco, and approved by Buffum. Also sent to USUN and repeated to Amman, Beirut, Cairo, Damascus, Jerusalem, and to Geneva for Goldberg.
/2/Reference is to a June 14 speech by King Hussein in which, inter alia, he declared his rejection of "the absurd logic and the weak policy which advocates keeping Palestinians in tents and camps surrounded by barbed wire." Telegram 787 from Amman, June 20, transmitted that portion of his speech. (Ibid., POL 15-1 JORDAN) The Embassy in Amman commented on the speech in telegrams 776, June 15, and 778, June 16, highlighting what telegram 778 called the King's "blistering attack" on the PLO, and his charge that the peril of Communism was greater and more dangerous than that of Zionism. (Both ibid.)
/3/A memorandum of Rafael's July 26 conversation with Hare is ibid., REF ARAB. A memorandum of his July 27 conversation with Hare and Sisco is ibid., REF 3 UNRWA.
Source: Schwar, Harriet Dashiell. (Ed.). Foreign Relations of the United States, 1964-1968, V. 18, Arab-Israeli Dispute 1964-1967. DC: GPO, 2001.